Confucius' refusal to buy a coffin for Yan Yuan was not out of coldness, but rather out of respect and adherence to the rites. In the social context of the time, the rites were an insurmountable social norm for Confucius.
教学团队
课程特色
视频(28)
考试(25)
文档(3)
讨论(3)
最新学员
Sharing your ideas of Confucius's choice on Yan Yuan's funeral.
Question: How do you comment on Confucius’s refusal to pay for buying a shell for Yan Yuan’s coffin? Does it show Confucius's lack of sincerity in his "love" toward his so-called "favorite" student?
334 回复
-
-
Confucius' refusal to buy a shell for Yan Yuan's coffin can be seen as an expression of his deep love and respect for his disciple. Confucius' actions reflect his belief that the value of a person's life cannot be measured in terms of material possessions. Instead, it's the inner qualities and virtues that really matter. Confucius' refusal to pay for the shell demonstrates his commitment to upholding these values, as well as his deep love and respect for Yan Yuan. Therefore, it was not a lack of sincerity in his "love" for his so-called "favorite" student, but rather a profound expression of his love and respect for him.
-
- Adhering to the Principle of Rites: Confucius dedicated his whole life to advocating and upholding the Zhou rites. In his view, the scale of a funeral should be strictly carried out in accordance with one's status and the rites system. Although Yan Yuan was an extremely admired and beloved disciple of Confucius, during his lifetime, he was just an ordinary civilian without any corresponding official position or noble status that would entitle him to a grand burial.
- Valuing the Essence of Inner Emotions: The master-disciple relationship between Confucius and Yan Yuan was extremely profound. Yan Yuan was a person of noble character, content with a simple life despite poverty, and highly knowledgeable, being an ideal moral practitioner in Confucius' mind.
-
Confucius is famous for his teaching of etiquette (propriety) and the proper code of conduct of the individual in society. He stressed the importance of following rituals while maintaining a balance between personal feelings and social norms. In the case of Yan Yuan's death, Confucius's reluctance to spend more money to buy the shell for Yan Yuan can be seen as an adherence to these principles. Instead of being insincere about the so-called " beloved " student. 1. Frugality and moderation: Confucius probably thought it important to practice frugality and moderation, even in times of mourning. Overspending could be seen as showing off, at odds with the austere principles he often advocates. 2. Proper etiquette: Confucius attached great importance to the proper execution of ceremonies according to one's status and circumstances. If he thought the more expensive coffins did not conform to the proper decorum of the circumstances, he might refuse to preserve the purity of the ceremony. 3. Set an example: By refusing unnecessary expenses, Confucius may have set an example to other disciples and the general public. Showing true respect and love does not necessarily require material expression. 4. Avoid favoritism: It is also possible that Confucius wanted to avoid showing favoritism because it might undermine the sense of equality among his disciples and in the community.
-
Confucius’ refusal to pay for the outer shell of Yan Yuan’s coffin reflects his emphasis on ritual propriety, status, and responsibility, rather than a lack of affection for Yan Yuan. He believed that, as a master, walking on foot to exchange for the coffin shell would violate ritual decorum. He also placed the responsibility for the funeral on the disciples rather than himself. At the same time, he clearly expressed his deep affection for Yan Yuan, emphasizing spiritual recognition over material support.
-
Adherence to Rituals
Confucius firmly opposed the idea of giving Yan Yuan a lavish burial proposed by his disciples. In Confucius's view, rituals were the norms and guidelines of society at that time, and everyone should abide by them. Yan Yuan was a commoner, and according to the ritual system, he did not qualify for a grand burial. Confucius's choice was to uphold the authority and order of the ritual system.
Consideration of Yan Yuan's Character
Yan Yuan lived a simple and frugal life, adhering to the principle of "a single bamboo dish of rice to eat, a single gourd dish of water to drink, and living in a humble alley." Confucius believed that a simple burial was more in line with Yan Yuan's character and values. A luxurious burial would go against Yan Yuan's usual practice and beliefs.
Expression of True Emotion
Although Confucius opposed a grand burial for Yan Yuan, it did not mean that he did not cherish his disciple. On the contrary, he had a deep affection for Yan Yuan. His refusal was based on the rational choice of adhering to rituals, but his grief and love for Yan Yuan were also evident in his words and deeds, showing that he could balance emotional expression and ritual norms.
-
1.Adherence to Rituals
Confucius firmly believed in and strictly adhered to the "rituals" of Zhou Dynasty. He thought that everything should be done in accordance with the rules of etiquette. Yan Yuan was of humble origin and did not hold a high social position, so a grand burial would have violated the norms of funeral rituals at that time. Confucius' objection was to maintain the solemnity and orderliness of the ritual system.
2.Consideration of Yan Yuan's Character
Yan Yuan lived a simple and frugal life, adhering to the principle of "a single basket of rice and a ladle of water in a humble alley." Confucius knew that he would not have wanted a lavish funeral. Therefore, from the perspective of respecting Yan Yuan's character and values, Confucius did not agree to the thick burial proposed by his disciples.
3.Expression of True Affection
Confucius had a deep affection for Yan Yuan, regarding him almost as his own son. However, precisely because of this deep relationship, he wanted to handle Yan Yuan's funeral in a more appropriate and sincere way, rather than simply using a grand burial to show off. He believed that true respect and remembrance for the deceased came from the heart, not from the extravagance of the funeral.
4.Influence on Disciples
Confucius hoped that through his actions and decisions, he could teach his disciples the importance of following rituals and the correct way to express emotions. Although his disciples finally buried Yan Yuan thickly, Confucius' attitude and words still had a profound educational significance, guiding them to think about the true meaning of "ritual" and how to balance emotions and reason.
-
Confucius' choice of funeral rites for his disciple Yan Yuan reflects his deep affection for his student and his adherence to Confucian values. Yan Yuan was one of Confucius' most outstanding disciples, and Confucius greatly admired his intelligence and virtue. For Yan Yuan's funeral, Confucius chose a simple and respectful approach, which not only reflects his recognition of Yan Yuan's life of modesty and pursuit of inner virtue, but also conveys the Confucian belief in the importance of inner virtue over external luxury.
Through such funeral arrangements, Confucius conveyed a moral message to his disciples and society: true respect and mourning do not lie in external grandeur and luxury, but in acknowledging and mourning the Yan Yuan's character and contributions. This choice also aligns with Confucius' concept of "ren," emphasizing genuine relationships between people and a pursuit of morality.
In summary, Confucius' choice of burial rituals for Yan Yuan not only reflected his personal emotions, but also deeply reflected the core values of Confucianism.
-
Confucius' actions at Yan Yuan's funeral can be evaluated from different aspects.
On one hand, it showed his deep affection and grief for Yan Yuan. Yan Yuan was one of his most outstanding disciples, and Confucius held him in high regard. His emotional display at the funeral demonstrated the sincere bond between them, highlighting that he cared not just about teaching knowledge but also about the personal connection with his students.
On the other hand, some of his behaviors might also be seen as adhering to certain ritual norms of that time. In ancient society, funerals were occasions with strict ritual requirements, and Confucius, as a proponent of propriety, likely followed those to some extent to set an example of how to handle such solemn events properly.
Overall, Confucius' actions at Yan Yuan's funeral were a combination of personal emotions and the manifestation of ritual propriety, which together reflected his complex inner world and his attitude towards life and death within the cultural context of that era.
-
Confucius thinks that rituals should reflect sincerity rather than extravagant displays of wealth. By refusing to pay for an ornate coffin, he may have been adhering to his belief that simplicity and genuine mourning are more important than material adornments. For Confucius, excessive spending on funerals might signify a focus on superficiality rather than a heartfelt expression of grief.Confucius’s love for Yan Yuan was evident in his frequent praise of Yan Yuan’s virtue and character. His refusal to purchase a shell might reflect a philosophical stance that true “love” or respect for someone is shown through adherence to ethical principles, rather than through material acts. Confucius might have believed that honoring Yan Yuan through a proper but simple burial upheld these principles
-
Conflict between personal feelings and social norms: Confucius may have faced a conflict between personal feelings and social norms at Yan Yuan's funeral. As a great educator and thinker, Confucius emphasized the importance of rites, but his emotions could transcend these norms when faced with the death of a close disciple.
Confucius Values: In Confucius' teachings, filial piety and respect for the dead are very important. He may show deep sorrow for his disciple at Yan Yuan's funeral, which reflects his respect for his disciple and the value he places on life.
Social impact: Confucius' actions often serve as role models for society to emulate. His choices at Yan Yuan's funeral may influence others' attitudes towards funerals and death, thus spreading his values in society.
Balance between personal and public roles: Confucius' behavior at Yan Yuan's funeral may have been a balancing act between his role as an individual and as a public moral leader. He needs to express his personal feelings while also taking into account the impact of his actions on society.
-
1. Adherence to Ritual: In ancient China, there were strict rules and rituals surrounding funerals and burials. Confucius’s refusal to pay for the shell might have been in accordance with these rituals, which dictated what was appropriate for a person’s status and circumstances.
2. Expression of Love: Confucius’s relationship with Yan Yuan was indeed profound, and his love and care for his student were expressed through education, guidance, and moral support. The act of not paying for the shell does not necessarily reflect a lack of sincerity; it could be seen as an adherence to the principles that governed their society. -
Confucius' choice regarding Yan Yuan's funeral rituals reflects his deep respect for traditional customs and his high regard for Yan Yuan. In ancient China, funeral rituals were considered extremely important, as they not only honored the deceased but also reflected the moral and social status of the family and community.
-
Confucius was deeply committed to the rituals and social norms of his time, which included the appropriate conduct for funerals. When Yan Yuan died, Confucius was asked by Yan Yuan's father, Yan Lu, to sell his carriage to buy an outer coffin. Confucius refused, stating that he could not walk on foot to follow other officials who rode in their carriages, as it would be improper for someone of his status . This shows that Confucius was abiding by the Zhou Rites, which dictated the appropriate behavior for individuals of different social standings.
Confucius was clear in distinguishing between personal emotions and the performance of social rituals. He maintained that personal feelings should not override the established rites and laws . This does not indicate a lack of sincerity in his love for Yan Yuan but rather a steadfast adherence to the principles that governed social conduct.
In conclusion, Confucius's actions should not be interpreted as a lack of sincerity or love for Yan Yuan. Instead, they reflect his commitment to the principles of propriety and the social order, which were central to his teachings. His personal grief and respect for Yan Yuan were evident, but they did not compromise his adherence to the rites and the social norms of his time.
-
Confucius's choice on Yan Yuan's funeral rituals reflects his strict adherence to ritual norms. He opposed an extravagant burial for Yan Yuan despite their deep bond. This decision emphasized the importance of propriety and balance between personal affection and social conventions. It set an example for disciples, teaching them to respect rites and not be swayed merely by emotions, which had a profound and lasting impact on traditional values.
-
This decision underscores Confucius’s belief that rituals should be meaningful rather than ostentatious. By focusing on simplicity and sincerity, Confucius demonstrated that the true essence of mourning lies in heartfelt respect and grief rather than in expensive ceremonies. His actions also emphasize the value of humility and the importance of aligning one’s practices with one’s means and virtues.
-
I think what Confucius did was first of all to follow the ritual. Confucius practiced and respected "rites" all his life. According to Confucius, nothing can be done contrary to the rules of etiquette. Yan Yuan's family was poor, and its status and financial resources determined that he could not get a generous burial after his death. Secondly, Confucius respected Yan Yuan's wishes. Yan Yuan was poor and simple and always followed the etiquette. Confucius knew very well Yan Yuan's character and personality, and thought that a generous burial was against Yan Yuan's original heart. According to Confucius, Yan Yuan had already lived a simple life in his lifetime, and after his death he did not need an overly lavish funeral to show his status or status.
-
Confucius' choice of Yan Yuan's funeral reflects his strict adherence to the ritual system and reasonable control over emotions. Even in extreme sadness, he did not give up his insistence on ritual, demonstrating his principles as a Confucian philosopher and the balance between emotions and reason.
-
Confucius emphasized the importance of propriety,believing it to be the cornerstone of social order and interpersonal relationships.At Yan Yuan's funeral,Confucius would likely adhere to the appropriate rites,and might also use the opportunity to teach his other disciples about the significance of life and death,propriety,and morality.
-
-
-
1. Confucius had been a doctor before, and he believed that there should be corresponding rules of etiquette in the corresponding positions, "self-denial and retribution", and "etiquette" could not be violated.
2. He was very poor, and there was no need to sell a car and buy a coffin.
-
In ancient Confucian traditions, the funeral rituals were of great significance and were seen as manifestations of filial piety and respect for the deceased.
Regarding Yan Yuan's funeral ritual, it reflects several aspects. Firstly, Yan Yuan was one of Confucius's most beloved disciples. His premature death was a great pity. Confucius's deep grief and the way he handled the funeral showed his strong emotional bond with the disciple. It was not just a matter of going through the motions of a ritual but an expression of sincere mourning.
From a cultural perspective, the attention to the proper steps and details of the funeral ritual adhered to the social and ethical norms of that time. It emphasized the importance of solemnity and propriety in sending off the deceased. Confucius's actions in this regard might have also set an example for others on how to conduct funerals with due respect and dignity, influencing the way people in that era and later generations regarded funeral ceremonies within the framework of Confucian values.
However, in modern times, while we still respect the cultural connotations behind such ancient funeral rituals, our understanding and practices have evolved. We focus more on commemorating the good qualities and contributions of the deceased in different, more contemporary ways while still drawing on some elements of traditional respect for life and the significance of proper send-offs.
-
One: Adherence to the Confucian Principle of "Emphasizing Care During Life and Simplifying Funerals"
As the founder of Confucianism, Confucius advocated the principle of "emphasizing care during life and simplifying funerals," which means that one should diligently care for elders while they are alive and avoid excessively luxurious funerals after their passing. This principle was exemplified in Yan Yuan's funeral. According to records, when Yan Yuan passed away, his disciples wanted to hold an elaborate funeral for him, but Confucius firmly opposed it. This reflects Confucius's adherence to the Confucian principle and his emphasis on returning funerals to their essence while avoiding extravagance.
Two: Focus on Economic Practicality and Alignment with Family Circumstances
When answering a question about funeral equipment from a disciple, Confucius clearly stated that funerals should align with the family's actual economic situation. He believed that if the economic conditions permitted, one should not exceed the proper rites for a funeral; if the conditions were insufficient, simply using clothing and blankets to cover the body and burying it soon after would not incur blame for violating the rites. This viewpoint was also reflected in Yan Yuan's funeral. Although Yan Yuan was a favored disciple of Confucius, Confucius did not agree to hold an elaborate funeral for him, instead adhering to practicality and economic considerations. -
Confucius’s refusal to sell his carriage to buy an outer shell for Yan Yuan’s coffin does not demonstrate a lack of sincerity in his love for his student. Instead, it reflects his deep respect for the social norms and rituals of his time, which were central to Confucian philosophy.
It shows Confucius' choose of personal love between his public spirits.
-
Confucius's choice regarding Yan Yuan's funeral rituals reflects a profound balance between personal feelings and public codes. Yan Yuan was Confucius's favorite disciple, and his early death must have deeply saddened Confucius. However, Confucius, as a proponent of propriety and social order, would have also been bound by the established public codes of funeral rituals. In this situation, Confucius likely aimed to uphold the proper rites while still expressing his personal grief. Funeral rituals in Confucianism are significant not only as a way to show respect for the deceased but also as a manifestation of social harmony and order. Confucius probably conducted Yan Yuan's funeral in a manner that was respectful of the norms and values of society, yet also managed to convey his deep affection and sorrow for his disciple. This choice shows Confucius's wisdom in navigating the complex relationship between personal emotions and public morality. It sets an example of how one should respect social order while still remaining true to one's feelings.
-
Confucius's approach to the funeral rituals for his beloved disciple Yan Yuan reflects his deep personal feelings and his commitment to the principles of propriety (禮/lǐ) and filial piety (孝/xiào), which are central to Confucian thought.
When Yan Yuan died, Confucius was deeply grieved and wanted to provide him with an elaborate funeral, which would have been in line with showing respect and affection for someone of great importance. However, Confucius also valued the principle of moderation and the observance of social norms. In the end, he did not go against the established ritual standards, even though it meant that the funeral might not reflect the full extent of his personal sorrow or Yan Yuan’s significance to him.
-
-
The disciples of Confucius eventually buried Yan Hui in a lavish manner, which caused dissatisfaction among Confucius. Confucius emphasized that this was not his intention, but the result of his disciples' own initiative. This indicates that even in times of grief, Confucius remained rational and did not violate social norms due to personal emotions. His attitude is not only a respect for Yan Hui personally, but also a maintenance of the entire social order and ritual system. Confucius believed that the implementation of the ritual system is the cornerstone of social stability, and any behavior that goes beyond the ritual system will have an impact on social order.
Confucius' view on Yan Hui's funeral deeply reveals his balance between emotions and ritual. In Confucius' view, the ritual system is the cornerstone of social order and an unbreakable principle. Even in the face of the death of a disciple who was as close as a father and son, he still adhered to this principle, demonstrating a high sense of propriety and rationality. This attitude is not only a restraint on his personal emotions.
-
Confucius chose to follow the funeral rites for Yan Yuan, which reflects his emphasis on and respect for social rites. His deep affection for Yan Yuan could also be expressed in other ways rather than just through the funeral. For example, Confucius' sorrow was palpable, and he expressed it through his actions. This shows that Confucius sought a balance between personal feelings and public norms, neither violating social norms nor failing to express personal feelings appropriately.
添加回复
您确定给 “0” 位老师发送协议吗？
UMOOCS用户服务协议
问题分类：
--
4008987008