I think this event indicates that Confucius stuck to the Li as although he adored Yan Yuan very much, he would not disobey Li for his favor and grievance.
教学团队
课程特色
视频(28)
考试(25)
文档(3)
讨论(3)
最新学员
Sharing your ideas of Confucius's choice on Yan Yuan's funeral.
Question: How do you comment on Confucius’s refusal to pay for buying a shell for Yan Yuan’s coffin? Does it show Confucius's lack of sincerity in his "love" toward his so-called "favorite" student?
334 回复
-
-
-
He might have emphasized simplicity yet solemnity in line with the ethical and ritual norms of that time. Confucius attached great importance to rituals in general, and for Yan Yuan's funeral, he would have wanted everything to be done appropriately to send off this disciple with dignity while also expressing his profound sense of loss.
-
Confucius's choice regarding Yan Yuan's funeral rituals highlights his emphasis on filial piety and moral character. Yan Yuan was one of Confucius's most beloved disciples, known for his diligence and virtue. By conducting a solemn funeral, Confucius underscored the importance of recognizing one's moral qualities and contributions. This act illustrates the connection between personal virtue and societal values, emphasizing that appropriate rituals honor the deceased while serving as a model for others. It reflects the significance of rituals in Confucian thought and the importance of virtue in relationships.
-
In summary, Confucius's decisions
regarding Yan Yuan's funeral encapsulate core Confucian values: respect for virtue, the importance of ritual, the influence of personal relationships, and the expression of grief. These values contribute to the broader understanding of morality and ethics in society and continue to influence people today.
-
-
-
While Confucius had a deep respect and fondness for Yan Yuan, he believed that focussing on material possessions and formalities would distract from the important life lessons that he was teaching. He opted to make a tribute to Yan Yuan's memory by honoring him through his teachings and by continuing to teach his remaining students.
Confucius' decision not to pay for the shell of Yan Yuan's coffin was in line with his teachings and his philosophy of seeking greater and deeper meanings beyond material possessions. It does not reflect a lack of sincerity or love for his student.
-
Confucius's teachings emphasized the importance of propriety, integrity , and the golden mean, which advocated for moderation and balance in all things. His actions, including his refusal to buy an expensive shell for Yan Hui's coffin, may reflect these principles rather than a lack of sincerity in his affection for Yan Hui.
-
This statement is a misinterpretation of Confucius.
In Confucian thought, Confucius had deep affection for Yan Yuan. In ancient times, the use of shells in coffins was a matter related to certain cultural and ritual norms. Confucius' actions were likely based on his strict adherence to the appropriate rituals and his understanding of the overall situation at that time, rather than any lack of sincerity.
Confucius emphasized propriety and moral teachings. His relationship with Yan Yuan was based on the transmission of knowledge, moral cultivation, and a sincere teacher - student bond. We should view historical figures and events from a comprehensive and accurate historical and cultural perspective to avoid misinterpreting them. -
Confucius advocated and practiced the principle of "self-restraint and restoration of propriety" throughout his life, emphasizing the use of propriety to regulate behavior and social order At Yan Yuan's funeral, Confucius refused the proposal of a lavish burial for his family members because it did not conform to Yan Yuan's social status and violated the regulations on funeral standards in the Zhou ritual This indicates that Confucius still chose to uphold the authority and normativity of ritual when faced with conflicts between emotions and ritual, viewing ritual as a code of conduct
Deep affection for disciples. Although Confucius did not agree with the lavish burial of Yan Yuan, his feelings for Yan Yuan were deep.
-
-
Confucius’s refusal to pay for the shell for Yan Yuan’s coffin can be seen as a demonstration of his principles rather than a lack of sincerity. Confucius believed in the importance of virtue and propriety, and he may have felt that spending money on an extravagant funeral item was not in alignment with those values. His actions likely reflect his commitment to moral integrity and the idea that one should not indulge in excessive materialism, even in matters of respect for a loved one. Thus, it doesn't necessarily indicate a lack of love for Yan Yuan, but rather a reflection of Confucius’s broader philosophical stance.
-
-
Confucius' approach to the funeral rites for Yan Hui demonstrates his deep respect for propriety and the Confucian principles of filial piety and proper conduct, even in death.
This decision reflects several key aspects of Confucian thought:
1.Frugality and Practicality: Confucius believed in living simply and avoiding excess. By opting for a less extravagant coffin, he set an example of how to honor someone without unnecessary lavishness, which aligns with the virtue of frugality valued in Confucianism.
2.Respect for Tradition and Protocol: Although some might argue that accepting the finer coffin would have shown greater respect for Yan Hui, Confucius adhered to what he deemed as appropriate within their social context. His choice was guided by traditional values and his understanding of what constituted respectful behavior.
3.Personal Integrity and Principle: Refusing the offer demonstrated Confucius’ commitment to maintaining personal integrity and upholding his principles, even when it came to matters of great emotional significance such as the burial of a loved one.
4.Moral Education through Example: Through this act, Confucius taught others the importance of making decisions based on ethical considerations and moral principles rather than material wealth or status symbols.
In essence, Confucius’ actions regarding Yan Hui’s funeral serve as a case study in how to balance respect with practicality, tradition with innovation, and personal integrity with communal expectations—all central themes within Confucian philosophy.
-
Confucius's approach to the funeral rituals for his beloved disciple Yan Yuan reflects his deep personal feelings and his commitment to traditional values, which are central to Confucian thought. When Yan Yuan died, Confucius was deeply grieved and insisted on providing a lavish funeral, despite the financial strain it would cause him.
-
It's important to understand the cultural and historical context in which this event occurred. In ancient China, the practice of using shells or other precious items as decorations or offerings for the deceased was quite common. However, this does not necessarily mean that Confucius's refusal to pay for the shell reflects a lack of sincerity in his feelings for Yan Yuan.
Confucius believed that material possessions were not the most important aspect of honoring the deceased. Instead, he may have focused on the spiritual and moral values that were more lasting and meaningful. By not paying for the shell, he may have been emphasizing the importance of these values over material wealth.
-
-
Confucius’s refusal to pay for a shell to encase Yan Yuan’s coffin is a nuanced incident that reveals important aspects of his philosophy and values, rather than simply calling into question his sincerity or affection toward his students.
Adherence to Simplicity: Confucius was deeply committed to the principles of simplicity and moderation in all aspects of life, including funerals. Elaborate burials contradicted his advocacy for restraint and focus on inner virtues rather than external displays. His refusal to add a shell to Yan Yuan’s coffin could be interpreted as staying true to these ideals, even in an emotional situation.
Philosophical Consistency: Confucius believed in setting an example through personal conduct. Yielding to societal pressures for extravagance in honoring Yan Yuan, even as a favored student, might have sent a conflicting message to his followers about the importance of moral consistency over material display.
-
-
Confucius's Decision Regarding Yan Yuan＇s Funeral: An Interpretation.Confucius, known for his profound wisdom and deep respect for rituals, faced a significant dilemma concerning the proper conduct of Yan Yuan's funeral arrangements. Yan Hui, or Yan Yuan, was one of Confucius' most devoted and beloved disciples, renowned for his exceptional intellect and adherence to virtue. When Yan Hui passed away, Confucius was confronted with the task of deciding on the appropriate way to honor him, a choice that would reflect both his respect for Yan Hui and his principles regarding propriety and filial piety.
-
Confucius' decision to personally attend Yan Yuan's funeral and express his grief demonstrates the importance he placed on the teacher-student relationship. In ancient China, the bond between a teacher and student was considered sacred, and Confucius himself emphasized the virtue of loyalty and respect in this relationship. By attending the funeral, Confucius was not only paying his respects to Yan Yuan but also upholding the traditional values of filial piety and respect for elders that were central to his teachings.
-
Confucius's thought of “benevolence” emphasized love with distinction. While he had deep affection for Yan Yuan, it didn't mean he would sacrifice the principles of rituals. His love was expressed in other ways, such as his high praise for Yan Yuan's character and learning, and his deep grief at Yan Yuan's early death.Confucius knew Yan Yuan's character well and believed that Yan Yuan himself would also adhere to the principle of thrift. Therefore, he did not agree to the thick burial proposed by others, which was also a kind of respect and true care for Yan Yuan.
-
-
Confucius advocated and practiced the principle of "self-restraint and restoration of propriety" throughout his life, emphasizing the use of propriety to regulate behavior and social order At Yan Yuan's funeral, Confucius refused the proposal of a lavish burial for his family members because it did not conform to Yan Yuan's social status and violated the regulations on funeral standards in the Zhou ritual This indicates that Confucius still chose to uphold the authority and normativity of ritual when faced with conflicts between emotions and ritual, viewing ritual as a code of conduct
Deep affection for disciples. Although Confucius did not agree with the lavish burial of Yan Yuan, his feelings for Yan Yuan were deep.
-
Confucius's handling of Yan Yuan's funeral rituals showcases his strict adherence to propriety and social hierarchy.His decision to not exceed the prescribed rites,despite his deep sorrow,underscores his commitment to maintaining order and harmony in society.It also reflects the importance he placed on following established customs,even in times of personal loss.
-
Emphasis on Ritual and Emotional Response: Confucius believed that appropriate ritual and emotional responses were crucial in dealing with death. He emphasized that the feelings of loss and the ritual expression of those feelings represented the height of human civilization and culture[^0^]。This suggests that Confucius saw funeral rituals not just as a way to honor the deceased but also as a means to express and process grief in a structured and meaningful way.
-
Confucius's refusal to pay for a shell for Yan Yuan's coffin reflects his principles of moderation and focus on spiritual over material values. It does not indicate a lack of sincerity in his love for his student, but rather his belief that true respect should be based on moral and spiritual qualities.
-
Confucius's behavior was very rational. Confucius refused Yan Yuan father Yan Road to sell cars to bury Yan Yuan's request, that a thick burial violates the ritual. Confucius believed that funerals should be done according to one's ability and should not exceed the scope of one's family and financial resources. This attitude of Confucius reflects his balance between personal emotion and ritual. Although he was deeply saddened by Yan Yuan's death, he insisted on the principle that funerals should follow the ritual system and should not be violated due to personal feelings. This attitude reflects Confucius' emphasis on ritual and adherence to social norms.
-
Confucius chose to follow the funeral rites for Yan Yuan, which reflects his emphasis on and respect for social rites. His deep affection for Yan Yuan could also be expressed in other ways rather than just through the funeral. For example, Confucius' sorrow was palpable, and he expressed it through his actions. This shows that Confucius sought a balance between personal feelings and public norms, neither violating social norms nor failing to express personal feelings appropriately.
添加回复
您确定给 “0” 位老师发送协议吗？
UMOOCS用户服务协议
问题分类：
--
4008987008