课程已结束,不允许加入和购买

第2次开课

开始:2020-02-20

截止:2020-06-16

课程已进行至

17/17周

成绩预发布时间 2020-06-15

期末考试截止时间 2020-06-14 23:55

教学团队

广东外语外贸大学
教授
广东外语外贸大学
副教授
广东外语外贸大学
讲师
广东外语外贸大学
讲师
广东外语外贸大学
广东外语外贸大学
讲师
广东外语外贸大学
讲师
广东外语外贸大学
讲师
广东外语外贸大学
讲师
广东外语外贸大学
讲师

课程特色

视频(29)
讨论(16)
考试(16)
文档(19)
下载资料(11)

电影(Troy)观后感!

By 李惠胤 老师 2020-04-22 4343次浏览

Hector 和Archilles一直是我喜欢的两位人物,一位是特洛伊城邦的王子,英俊勇敢,最欣赏他的有担当;另一位则是是海洋女神忒提斯(Thetis)和凡人英雄珀琉斯(Peleus)之子。电影Troy (2004) 诠释一个脍炙人口妇孺皆知的神话故事, 讲述了无法逃避自身悲剧命运的英雄。电影中既有战争和死亡,也有温情和尊严。在课程Unit 5 Heroes in Greek Mythology中,新加入一个课时Movie Troy,是电影Troy的一个片段:Hector与Archilles的对决。请观看后写下自己的感想,相互交流一下。语言可以用中文,也可以用英文!

152 回复

  • 赖晓琳 2020-05-03

    Facing with the choice between getting into the battle with Achilles and depolying armies to the battle,Hector chose the latter. And in the alternative courses opened up to Achilles, revenge for his friend to beat Hector down and then be famous or live in obscurity to death.Achilles chose to fight.

    Hector was more for his empire,to show his people that thier prince was too fearless to yield to enemies,he was a reliable prince,he fighted for his people or the glory of his family.And Achilles,he was triggered his anger by the death of his best friend,but i would rather to say he was for himself,for being well-known,for being imprinted in everyone's memory.

    I cant judge either of thier decisions of this battle,to say which is right and which is wrong.Hector,he was prince of the empire,it was his duty to protect his people in the frontline,it might seems a bit of reckless and impulsive,but at the same time it felt safe to have a leader who would not just sitting there and using mouth for wars.And Achilles,maybe someone argue that he was too aggressive and too selfish,but isnt good at least he wanted to fight for his faith and didnt want to live as no one?At least he knew what he was chasing at and took actions to make it be realized.That's my opinions for two charaters.

    回复
  • 许晴 2020-05-03

    Hector:

    In this clip, Hector faced the dilemma of whether to fight against Achilles because it's a losing battle for him. He chose to fight for his people. 

    As the prince and first warrior of Troy, Hector was known as the "wall of Troy" for his bravery and military prowess during the war. Hector loved his family, his brothers, his wife and his son.When his brother Paris took the queen of Greece and started the Trojan war for ten years, he took up his shield and spear to clean up his brother's mess. Before the battle, he tenderly took leave of his son, holding him in his arms and praying to Zeus, which showed that he is a hero with love. Hector once said to his soldiers, "Honor the gods, love your women, and defend your country!" He fought for his country and his people. His power came from his responsibility and mission for his country.

    Achilles:

    Faced with the dilemma of staying away from the war and taking revenge for his friend, Achilles chose to take revenge for his friend.

    As the  best warrior of ancient Greece, he was born with valor. He had a thirst for battle and adventure, and when he was angry, that showed a fierce cruelty.At the end of the battle, Achilles stripped Hector of his armor, pierced his feet with his cow sinews, and drove off in a carriage, dragging his body. The battle with Hector was more than a revenge, but also a fight for his own honor. Achilles regarded his own dignity and honor as the most important thing, even above the interests of the nation.

     In conclusion, both of two chose to participate in life actively and positively.

    回复
  • 蔡依敏 2020-05-03

    Hector:

    Hector, the idealistic hero in this world, is for the country for the people for the brothers, heavy feeling heavy justice, has compassion for the war, advocates peaceful coexistence, he loves the people love the country, is an absolutely perfect hero.

    He is tough and strong in appearance and full of love and tenderness in heart. He is not the representative of warrior spirit, nor does he believe in god too much. He is the embodiment of love and courage.

    He hated killing and he hated war but he had to fight for Troy for the people he loved, for his country, for his brother, for his wife and his son, for his people.

     

    Achilles:

    He has two different life can choose, one is an ordinary and happy life; the other is to fight for honor, and be remembered by history. Achilles chose the latter, the path of a natural warrior and a hero.

    Achilles is the pride of all Greece. He was very brave. He fought in the Trojan war and was called the first warrior of Greece. He had fought many times in battle to kill the enemy, several times let the Greek army back to win, he is a very strong warrior, very competitive and brave strong, and then heroic fighting, very brave. He is actually a very emotional person, loyal to friends and also a compassionate man, kind and upright. In short, his personality is too contradictory, cold cruel and kind, a real individualism hero.

    回复
  • 国贸1803刘韵怡 2020-05-03

    Hector:

    Hector is the prince of the Troy and the heir to the throne. When he faced the choices between life and collective honor and happiness, he chose the latter. In order to protect his country and his family, he chose to fight with Archilles fearlessly and bore his responsibility though he knew it was hard to win in the fighting. He hated war, but in order to defend his country, he turned his back on death. Hector is respected not only for his valor, but also for his noble humanity and refined character. From Hector, we can see the shadow of eastern traditional culture, which expresses a spirit of collectivism.

    Archilles:

    Archilles is the hero who seems to be born for war naturally. When he had the two choices between staying away from war and taking revenge for his good friends, he chose the latter. When his dignity was challenged by Agamemnon, between the army victory and his own dignity and honor, he also chose the latter. Archilles is a man of complex character. He is brave and always forget life and death in the war, but he is also brutal and unrestrained. He has a worshipping soul and a brutal animal nature at the sme time. In contrast to Hector's strong collectivism, Archilles lives for himself, for personal glory. His character is closer to the western tradition culture.

    回复
  • 陈思莹 2020-05-03

    Hector:

    Facing the revenge of Archilles, Hector could choose to stay inside the wall and refuse his furious fight. However, he chose another way, wearing his armor and facing Archilles’ challenge. 

    In the fight, he went all out to face Archilles' attack even ended up with death. As far as I am concerned, he is a man reflecting the meaning of “a man can be killed but not be defeated”, which is emphasized in Hemingway’s works. He fought for his nation’s glory and his dignity as well as his own dream of fighting with Archilles, the greatest hero. Although he died, he left without shame or pity. That’s why even he was lost in the fight, the people of his nation still honored him very much. So am I.

    His life may be short, may be long.

    Archilles:

    It's predicted that Archilles would die in the Troy War, but he chose to join it. That's the way he chose.

    In my view, he indeed was a great hero with outstanding ability and extraordinary courage, enjoying the respect and awe from others. However, he was so furious and cruel that he couldn't control his own temper, which even finally killed himself. Take an inappropriate example, Archilles represents the heroism while Hector symbolizes the collectivism. I’m not about to compare which one is better. To be honest, every way has its own beauty and uniqueness. If Archilles didn't join the war, we wouldn't know there was such a hero existing with fury and passion. It also indicates that even the hero has the flaw.

    回复
  • 洪泽清 2020-05-03

    For Hector, he is the prince of Troy and big brother of Paris. Based on the movie, Hector is not the source of Troy War, but his little brother. Still, he chose to fight against Archilles and died with honor. As a princess and the greatest warrior of his country, it is his duty to protect Troy. As a brother, he has to protect his little brother. There is no denying that Hector could have chosen to hide behind the wall and done nothing. But he fought. Even knowing that his rival is a half-god and formidable, he still fought. Not for himself, but for others. It’s touching and admirable for someone who could have a happy and peaceful life to die for others. He died in a young age but he died a meaningful death. It’s sad to see such a great man die but maybe that’s what he wants.

    For Archilles, he’s a half god and spear-proof. He can easily win a battle and killed someone effortlessly. As the leader of his army, he did a great job. As a rival, he’s formidable but also admirable. There’s a scene in the movie that touches me. Hector was tripped by a stone and hurt in the ankle. But Archilles did not pursue to kill him. Instead, he encouraged him to stand up and continue the fight. It’s rare to see that scene because the rival is the best warrior of the enemy and killing him means you may win the war. Archilles respects every rival and he won his fight without cheating. (but still…maybe his body cheats in some way.)

    回复
  • 董欢 2020-05-03

    Hector's choice is to live a peaceful and happy life & fight for his country and honor. As the first warrior of Troy, he chose to fight without flinching. He was the commander in chief of the Trojan War. He had a wonderful family, but for the sake of his country and his honor as a warrior, he resolutely took up his spear to fight. His aim was to protect his country. He was a good monarch, a good son, a good husband and a good father. He was almost a perfect man and a model for all people. He knew that he was invincible to Achilles, but as a prince, he was responsible to his people. Glory and responsibility were the driving force behind his fight.          

    Achilles’ choice is to to be free from war, to enjoy comfort &to be engaged in battle, to fight against the enemy. He attached great importance to friendship. In order to avenge his friends, he returned to the battlefield again and tried to kill Hector. He is the God of war loved and worshiped by all, and the embodiment of power. Fighting is the value of his training. He was born for war and died for war. On the battlefield, he made countless contributions and wiped out countless enemies for the king. He was narrow-minded and could not bear others to say that he was not good; he was cruel and cold-blooded, killing people regardless of men, women, old and young; but he was compassionate. When Apollo brought the plague to the Greeks, he first stood up and called on people to discuss solutions. In a word, Achilles is a complicated and changeable character.

    回复
  • 国经1802林宝然 2020-05-03

    The battle between Hector and Achilles reveal two choice of them.

    For Hector, he chose to devote himself to his nation. Before the bettle he said, If he duck the battle like a coward, he shall be ashamed of myself in the presence of my old brothers and my old brothers in Troy, and of the women of Troy in flowing dresses. He put his country's honor before his life.

    For Achilles, he fighted for his friend. The death of his friend angered him. He is willing to die for his friend. I could feel the importance of friendship in his heart. In the choice of life, he chose friendship but not himself.

    The same of their choice is that they put others before themself. I think this is the most important quality of a hero

    回复
  • 行管1801蒋双煜 2020-05-03

    Hector could have chosen to be a bystander or to fight for his country, but as the prince of his country he seemed to have no choice. Even if he had a premonition that he would die in this battle, he overcame his fear and went into the battle calmly. His sense of responsibility and mission interpreted the spirit of collectivism .

    Conversely,Achilles embodies individualism. He could have chosen peace, but he chose revenge for the death of his friend and started a new battle.They all have courage and strength, they all have faith and are willing to fight for it, and I can't say who is better because they are both heroes and they both try to make their lives shine, although I prefer the rational and selfless Hector.

    回复
  • I think Hector is a hero who takes death camly and is toyal to his contry.  He faced the choices that fighted with Achilles and then he would die but protect his country or escaped the battleground and then he would save but his country would be ruined. He chose the harder one to fight with Achilles. It is no doubt that he dead but his death is respected and stirring.

    As to Achilles, the enemy of Hector, I think he is also a hero but a little cold blooded. He also face two choices, to fight for his friend who was killed by Hector or do nothing. he fanilly chose to fight with Hector and killed him.

    I still appreciate Achilles' choice although he killed many people and ruined Hector's dead body. I can understand his feeling and their precious friendship.

    I think both of them are heroes. They all fight for the thing that they take it important and war is war no one can change its cruel so I think all the things they do are reasonable.

    回复
  • I think Hector is a hero who takes death camly and is toyal to his contry.  He faced the choices that fighted with Achilles and then he would die but protect his country or escaped the battleground and then he would save but his country would be ruined. He chose the harder one to fight with Achilles. It is no doubt that he dead but his death is respected and stirring.

    As to Achilles, the enemy of Hector, I think he is also a hero but a little cold blooded. He also face two choices, to fight for his friend who was killed by Hector or do nothing. he fanilly chose to fight with Hector and killed him.

    I still appreciate Achilles' choice although he killed many people and ruined Hector's dead body. I can understand his feeling and their precious friendship.

    I think both of them are heroes. They all fight for the thing that they take it important and war is war no one can change its cruel so I think all the things they do are reasonable.

    回复
  • 李美辰 2020-05-03

    Hector is not only awesome because of his bravery, but also his noble humanity. He hates war, but in order to protect his family and protect the country, he regards death as his home. And he has strong sympathy, thus creating his glorious tragic hero image;

    Achilles is superior to ordinary people, he has also become a self-centered hero, he is a slightly selfish, strong sense of revenge. But he also has strong compassion, so compared to Hector, Achilles lived for himself and for his personal honor;

    They are all heroes, and they cannot be compared, but we still remember In the formerthousands of years  Trojan War, the two unyielding heroes and soldiers.

     

    回复
  • 罗善茵 2020-05-03

    After Achilles was born, his mother Thetis learned from the goddess of destiny that he would die due to war, so Thetis kept trying to prevent it. Achilles's best friend, Patroclus, couldn't bear to see the Greek army dead and wounded seriously, put on the armor of Achilles, pretending to be his appearance, but he was killed by Hector. In the face of the Trojan War, Achilles faced two options, one was longevity but mediocre under the protection of Thetis, and the other was revenge for friends who risked the consequences of being killed on the battlefield. Achilles chose the latter because he cherished friendship so much. However,I think he is a very self-centered person. Judging from his cruel behavior towards Hercules, he doesn't think Hecules is a respectable opponent.

    When Hector was in a dilemma for the Trojan War,he  tried to stop the war as a mortal. But as the best warrior and leader of the country, he could only choose to fight. Knowing that he was going to die under Achilles's gun, he still chose to walk out of the gate of Troy and duel. Hector ’s credo in life is "Honor the gods, love your women, and defend your country!" He kept his promise in his short and great life. In my opinion, he is a true hero and the most respectable person.

    回复
  • 伍家乐 2020-05-03

    The moment Hector's heart was pierced by Achilles' sword, it really hurts me. Hector is the most attractive kind of ruler——brave, kind and always loving the rare peace. He took up his spear and shield only to take up the olive branch again!He fought hard just to get the fight over! I love him. I know that the two man placed here is to compare with each other to express the sense of existentialism and realism. But in my eyes, they are the same. They fought to crash the meaning of their life, to reach their goal and to realize their value. The difference is that their values stand on different sides.

    Achilles fought to be a legend. It is a great dream. The determination to be a hero and the way to be a legend is undoubtful great. What about Hector's? Though he is not a god, but in my eyes, His quest was to shoulder the well-being of the whole country, which is much more greater than a god who just fought for himself in this fight. I know Achilles is a ture hero and even a hero can not be pertect. But the actions he kill Hector and even insulting his body really hurt me.

    回复
  • 黄思妍 2020-05-04

    Hector is brave and responsible. He is a hero before the fight. He could have chosen not to  fight against Archille. But he didn't dodge, instead, choosing to fight braely. Because he have to protect the country, and protect those who love and support him.


    As for Archilles, he fought for his own honor. He is willing to take challenge and better himself even though he is powerful enough. Compared with Hector who fought for his nation, I think Archilles is a symbol of individualism. 


    The common thing shared by them is that they are both satified with their choice, no matter what is the result about. Therefore,the insparation  for me is that no matter what you choose, it is meaingful if you stand for it and protect it with your whole life.
     

    回复
  • 国贸1803潘奇禧 2020-05-04

    Hector:

    In my opinion, he is a responsible and brave man. After he kills Archilles' friend, Archilles came and asked him for duel. He could either stay alive or fight with him. But finally he choose to have a fight with Archilles. Although he was killed , he lived in people's heart permanent. He deserves our respect. He devote all his life to Troy. 

    Archilles:

    He is a man who regards his friends as important. He declared that  he won't take part in fighting until Agamemnon apologized . But when he knew his friend was killed by Hector, he came to fight for him without hesitation. He has a powerful body which made him invincible in the war.

    Both of them are heroes. They all play a significant role in the war. But the difference is that Hector is more selfless and what he cares about is his country, his people. By contrast, Archilles is more straight.

    回复
  • 国经1802杨如梦 2020-05-04

    For Hector, a prince of Troy, he had two choices when Achilles wanted to fight with him. One is to reject the fight with Achilles and to stay at the fortress, which can stay him alive at that time. The other is to fight with Achilles, which would risk his life but encourage his troop and defend his country. Clearly, he chose the latter, fighting for his country.

    Form his choice, we find that he was quite brave and responsible. For his country and people, he can risk his life. No matter he was dead or not, he can motivate his troop fight for their country. How strong the sense of nation honor he had! How brave the hero he was!

    When it comes to Achilles, the leader of the most valiant army in the army groups during Trojan War, he also faced a dilemma. One is to participate in the war, and the other is to keep living peacefully and comfortably. In fact, he had chosen three times. First, he chose to participate in the war for his own honor. Then he changed his mind when he met the priest of RA. Last, he came back the war to revenge for his friend.

    From his different choices, we can find his different aspects of personality. His first choice shows that he was a individualist, only fighting for his own honor. It seemed he was a selfish hero. The second choice made him more like a normal young man. He would give up his honor for his beloved girl. The last choice indicated that he was a man who attached much importance to friendship. In conclusion, Achilles is also a hero but different with Hector.

    回复
  • 陈免 2020-05-04

    Hector:

    Hector can choice to be a be a happy, honorable prince,but he didn’t. He bravely went to the battlefield to fight for his country.

    Hector left a deep impression with his heroic image of courage, affection and carefulness.At the same time, he is not a war but willing to die to defend the homeland of the heroic spirit.

    He was calm and brave, and his heart was full of collectivism.With the great enemy was before him, and he knew it was a lost battle, but for his tribe's sake,Undaunted, he settled down his wife and children and rushed off to war.He was a very affectionate man. He cared about the people, his parents, his wife, his brother,Care for the country and the people and love the people.Tribes, people, and loved ones were important to him, and he could not bear to see them suffer and die.

    Hector is not only a mortal made perfect by fate and tragedy, love and blood, but also a tragic hero made by fierce fighting and limited life.

    In my heart, he is a brave and immortal true hero

     

    Achilles:

    He could choose to live a comfortable life, but he chose to avenge his good friend Patroclus bravely.

    His character is manifold.He was at once naive and stubborn, at once cruel and kind, at once youthful and insolent and respectful of the old.In fairy tales, he is more human.The appearance of the image of Achilles is a shining signpost on the long road of human self-knowledge. There are three core elements in his many-faceted character. He had the spirit of selfless combat adventure, he did not hesitate to go to the battle field against the trojans, to seize territory. He valued friendship, though there was a violent side to his character. The brotherly friendship between Achilles and patroclus also shows the importance he attaches to friendship.

    He was after dignity and honor,He regards bravery as the highest honor, so he gets angry when others trample on his dignity.

    Every person is a whole, a world in itself, and every person is a whole and alive person,We see many aspects of human nature in his story,We also feel the glory of human nature

     

    回复
  • 卢桐潇 2020-05-04

    Hector:

    Hector knows that this is a war that is doomed to fail. He can choose to follow his wife's advice and leave the battlefield, but he chose to fight even though he gave his life for the honor of his tribe and people.

    In my opinion, Hector is a hero of brave, wise and compassionate but miserable. He is not a fighter, but he is willing to die to defend his homeland. He fought in the Trojan war as a human hero, bearing a lot of pressure from his country and family, but still with his strong will to go forward. He has not only the clank of lofty character, but also tender passion. His tenderness towards his wife and children and his tolerance towards his father and brother moved me. I lament his death and his fate. Hector makes me realize that heroes are real.

     

    Achilles:

    Achilles could have chosen to persist in refusing to go to war, but to avenge his friend Patroclus, who is killed by Hector, he still chose to fight.

    Achilles was the most powerful hero of the Greek army. He was a man of valor and war, who valued friendship. On the one hand, He has almost won every battle on the battlefield and has shown great fighting power. At the same time, he takes friendship very seriously and sincerely. On the other hand, he didn't care about nationalism, he was selfish and brutal. He is a hero, who is full of affection and love life.

    回复
  • 任子滢 2020-05-04

    The video clip shows the fight between Archilles and Hector. Maybe some of us will think Archilles a brutal and cold-blooded monster. In fact, he fights with Hector to take revenge for his best friend Patroclus who is killed by Hector. He joined Troy War to show his power, but he also shows his love for friends in the war. Well, Hector is a good husband and father, who is a prince with two coward brothers. He is the leader of Troy, fighting for his nation and people and family. So he never fear for death.

    I think both of them are brave and strong characters in Troy. Maybe Hector is more respectful, because he takes his responsibility to protect his country.

    回复
  • 国经1802陈泽深 2020-05-04

    For a further understanding about these two men, I watch the whole movie Troy. In the movie, Achilles’s two different destinies was told by his mother before he participated in the War of Troy. If he chose to join in the war, he would die in the war, or he would live a happy but normal life with his wife and children. Finally, Achilles decided to seek glory in the war, in order to make his name last through ages. In my opinion, Achilles is a utopian character. He was born with the meaning of his life and the gift to realize the meaning. He has great power and solid and pure ambition for glory. He doesn’t fight for any standpoint, the Greek people, his country or the emperor. Even when he dueled against Hector for revenge for his cousin, he tried to kill Hector in a decent and public way so as to keep his glory. I feel him respectable but I think maybe there are not so many people are as lucky and pure as him in the world.

    Hector was the prince of Troy. In the movie, he foresaw the chance that Troy can win this war is very slim and he could also escape from secret passage. But he chose to fight with the enemy to protect his homeland and finally sacrificed himself. Compared to Achilles, I think Hector is a more practical one. He cared about his people and life more than his own fame or glory. During the process he fight for his people and homeland, he realized the meaning of his life.

    Both of them are admirable and respectable heroes, who chase the meaning of their life.

    回复
  • 国贸1803付菀澄 2020-05-04

    The arrogant and rebellious Achilles, who had never yielded to the Greek king, had never been loyal to anyone, and had never been happy with King Agamemnon of Greece, decided to go to war in order to be remembered. 
    Hector was a calm, thoughtful, sensitive man who hated war but was determined to fight it for his country. In the face of the challenge of Achilles, knowing that one can not defeat Achilles, but for the sense of honor, or to go forward to fight. As he was the commander of Troy, if he did not fight, it would hurt the morale of the Trojan Army. In the end, Hector chose to fight, and was killed in battle by Achilles'men.

    Both of them participated in the war for honor and family. They could have refused the war, but they didn't. I think that Achilles was born to be belligerent, and in order to avenge his younger brother, he could not have participated in the war, and could have avoided tragedy. Hector chose glory in his peaceful life. In order to protect his weak brother and his city-state, he had to fight. Compared with Achilles, he has more responsibilities and more helplessness.

    回复
  • 国经1801陈楚儿 2020-05-04

    After watching this video, I feel really sad but proud for the death of Hector. Hector is a brave, affectionate and noble man. He was against war, but he fought to defend his country and people because he loved his country,his parents, his people and his children, and he loved his wife even more.
    Before Hector went to the war,when his wife cried and begged him to leave the battlefield, his first reaction was to refuse. Faced with the precipitous form, worried wife and young children, hector's heart is bound to be reluctant to give up. But he can't escape, even though knowing that this is a doomed to lose the war, but for the country, he resolutely took the step forward, he can't bear to see the people suffering, so he must fight with the enemy. From this can be seen, Hector is a strong appearance but the heart of tenderness and love of the man. And he was able to be considerate in such a critical moment. He recognized the severity of the situation, the strength of the enemy. Troy may soon be dead, and the people may be in trouble, but he calmly kisses his children, prays to the gods and tells his wife to be brave. Isn't such a man, shouldering dignity, honor and responsibility,a real hero? Knowing that he would be killed by Achilles, he went out alone to fight him. His courage wasn't the impulse of the moment, but the deliberation, the quiet face of the known outcome. His brother can be weak, but he can't. He had to assume his duties as prince, commander, brother and husband. He is a true hero for me.

    "Honor the gods, love your women, and defend your country!” This is a very simple principle of life, but he stuck to it in his short but great life. His death is full of tragic, but also shocked my heart. His death is proud because he traded life for the dignity of Troy.

    Achilles and Hector both have two roads that could be choose. Hector chose the difficult road to protect the country. But Achilles chose the road to fight for honor.

    By contrast, Achilles  is more common than Hector. He fought only to avenge for his friend and empower. He doesn't have the sense of responsibility that Hector has. He seemed only to be fighting for his own dignity and honor. But he also has advantages. He loved his mother and cherished his friendship, but he was cruel to his enemies. Especially after he killed Hector, tied his body to the chariot and dragged it three times around Troy. But when Hector's father begged to return his son's body, Achilles relented. He is really paradoxical but three-dimensional character. He was fierce, cruel, kind and brave.

    So Achilles, who is willing to ride, may become a dream about power, but Hector, who is responsible, is really the shoulder of power. This great prince who should have inherited the will of Troy may have a little ambition to be a hegemon, but this man who supports the motherland with all his heart is enough to become Troy's strongest guardian.

     

    收起
    • 黄绮雯 2020-06-13
      Good job! I think the article is well written. The author describes the characters of the two heroes in detail and compares them to express her own opinions. The part of Hercules shows his characteristics completely, and the detailed description makes me moved by Hercules' heroism. The part of Achilles gives a description of the character's contradictions from both positive and negative perspectives. But there are a few small flaws that could be improved. I think it would be a good idea to switch the two parts. First for Achilles, then for Hercules, and finally for which hero you prefer and the reason. This logic will be clearer, and the feelings of the article will appear layered.
  • 江佳淳 2020-05-04


    I like Hector better, although he is not as good as Achilles, but he is brave and meticulous, in order to defend the country to the end, can be said to be a tragic hero. A national hero Achilles during the Trojan war begins stubborn war, no matter the coalition anyway, until his good friend killde by wearing his golden armor in death, he didn't do this little puss-head, revenge for a friend, he again forces on the battlefield, killed Hector, and drove to bind his body in a chariot, although this is Achilles brutal side. Although he is also a tragic hero, he is the aggressor.Troy prince, Hector with its brave ,heavy feeling, meticulous hero image left a deep impression on me. At the same time, his heroic spirit that is not warrior but willing to die for the defense of the tribe heroic spirit let people in the moved also can not help but sigh.

    回复
  • 李卓霖 2020-05-04

    Hector, his two choices are to stay in the city as a cowardly prince, or to stand up bravely and fight for his country and honor. He was a brave and great hero. Even though he knew that he had little chance to defeat Achilles, he still went out of the city and fought bravely. He loved his country and his people. He chose to be a brave man to fight. Here he showed his bravery to the war and his loyalty to the people. Although this is a tragic figure, he is a true hero. Unlike Achilles, he was not a born warrior. His strength came from his responsibilities and the honor of his country. When his country was in danger, he had to leave his wife and children behind and take on the war for his cowardly brother. His heroic image deserves to be remembered.

    Achilles was doomed to live a long and safe life or be the hero of an early death. Because his whole body is invulnerable except his heels. He was a good fighter and won many battles. He didn’t fight for the honor of his country, but for his own glory, to be remembered. He was a man who wanted to fight, unlike Hector. He is also cruel. When he knows that his good friend has been killed, he takes revenge for him and kills Hector. He said he would rather die if he could not avenge his friend. After he killed Hector, he   dragged Hector's body around, but his cruelty also reflected his courage in the war and his loyalty to his friend.

    回复
  • 吴钰婷 2020-05-04

    Hector was a typical collectivist hero, fighting for tribes and nations. Hector had a premonition that his city-state would fall, that he would be killed by Achilles on the battlefield, that his wife would become a slave, but for the sake of the whole tribe, for the survival of the city, he faced death, which was the concentrated expression of his collectivism. The heroic prince of Troy addressed his men with these words: “Honor the gods, love your women, and defend your country!” I was deeply moved by his love for his family, his country and the collective good.

    Achilles is a typical example of personal heroism, fighting for dignity and honor. He went to war to show his power and ability. When Agamemnon took his female prisoners, he refused to fight, causing the greeks to lose the war, and Achilles' desire to fight was inspired only after his friend was killed by Hector. This shows that he is a man who values friendship.

    They are two very different people, but there are many criteria to judge a person, I can only say that I admire Hector's selflessness, but at the same time, Achilles' dedication to love and justice also touched me.

    回复
  • 赖家梁 2020-05-04

    Hector and Archilles were both the hero of the war. And both of them have no choice but to fight for their contry.

    Hector is the prince of the contry, and Archilles want to fight for his dead friend. They all choose the way they have to choose. 

    And I think that they are brave and reliable. They choose to be a man even though that might not be what they want to be. It is hard for people to stand into the battlefield, and they do all this by themselves.

    回复
  • 林蔼晴 2020-05-04

    In Greek mythology, Hector is the prince of Troy, he faces to the choices between peaceful life and fightinf for his country and his people, he chooses to fight for his country and protect his country's dignity. Thought he dead at last, his value of life had realized. He is a brave man with a sense of responsibility and dedication.

    Achilles is a  brave and warlike hero, he is facing the choices of live a peaceful life or fight for his honor. Between these two choices, he chose to fight for his honor. But i think he is a little arrogant. He is no more sense of responsibility of country, only fighting for himself, which is different from Hector. 

    回复
  • 赖家梁 2020-05-04

    Hector and Archilles were both the hero of the war. And both of them have no choice but to fight for their contry.

    Hector is the prince of the contry, and Archilles want to fight for his dead friend. They all choose the way they have to choose. 

    And I think that they are brave and reliable. They choose to be a man even though that might not be what they want to be. It is hard for people to stand into the battlefield, and they do all this by themselves.

    回复
  • 杨建豪国贸1803 2020-05-04

    The duel was a tragedy for both of them. Achilles, in order to avenge, resolutely violated the rules of the battlefield, about the enemy duel, and his body dragged dozens of miles, refused to return. This series of actions greatly reduced his heroic image; Hector decided that the moment he went out to meet the enemy he was going to die for his country, but he died with no dignity. In my opinion, Achilles was the most powerful hero in the Trojan war and Hector was the greatest hero in the Trojan war. Achilles was simply the most powerful, Hector the most perfect. Unfortunately, both of them are god's dolls.

    回复

添加回复