•Does professor Fei Xiaotong's concept of "differentiated love" suggest that Confucians claim a stronger love toward one’s own family, while the love grows thinner to others? How do you understand the extension of love in Confucianism?
The concept of "differentiated love" in Confucianism does not imply that Confucians have a stronger love for their own family members and less love for others. Instead, it suggests that love begins with the family and then expands outward in concentric circles. The idea is to start with the love for one's immediate family and gradually extend this love to include a broader community, ultimately aiming for a form of universal love that encompasses all people.
In Confucianism, the extension of love is based on the principle of starting with the closest relationships and then gradually extending care and concern to more distant ones. This is often visualized as a series of concentric circles, with the family at the center. The closer the relationship, the more immediate and intense the obligations of love and care. This does not mean that love is diminished for those outside the immediate family; rather, it is a recognition that our capacity to love is finite, and we must start with what is closest to us and then work outward. The goal is to cultivate a moral character that can extend this love to all, creating a harmonious society where everyone is cared for and respected.
Differentiated benevolence refers to showing different degrees or types of kindness and care.It might imply that benevolence is not uniformly distributed but is adjusted according to specific circumstances, relationships, or qualities of the recipients.For example, one might show more benevolence to family members than to strangers, which could be an instance of differentiated benevolence.
Fei Xiaotong's concept illustrates social relationships as concentric circles, with the individual at the center and connections growing less intense outward. In Confucianism, love is strongest within the family due to close bonds and duties but extends outward in a more general form of benevolence and respect toward all people. It's not that love diminishes for others, but it changes in nature, promoting harmony in wider society.
Fei Xiaotong's "differentiated love" doesn't mean that Confucian love is so simply graded. In Confucianism, love starts from family but extends outward. Loving one's family is the starting point. For example, filial piety is fundamental. However, this love doesn't stop at the family. Confucianism promotes the idea of "loving all people." Through self - cultivation, one can gradually expand the scope of love from relatives to neighbors, friends, and ultimately all of humanity. It is a continuous process of moral expansion based on the initial family - centered love.
Professor Fei Xiaotong's concept of "differentiated love" suggests that in Confucianism, individuals naturally prioritize love and responsibility towards their family, which is seen as a fundamental unit of society. This perspective implies that the intensity of love and care diminishes as one moves outward to the wider community and humanity. Confucians believe in a hierarchical extension of love, where familial bonds are paramount, followed by relationships with friends, neighbors, and then society at large. This tiered approach promotes social harmony by emphasizing the importance of nurturing intimate relationships before considering broader social obligations. Ultimately, this philosophy underscores the idea that strong familial ties serve as the foundation for cultivating virtue and extending benevolence towards others.
"Loving all people and being kind" is one of the core of Confucian ethics. It stresses the need for people to genuinely care for and respect all people and, on that basis, to become closer to and more trusting of their relatives and friends. This value embodies an interconnected idea that we should not just focus on ourselves and our loved ones, but should treat all with the same concern. It is only in this sense that society can produce genuinely beneficial mutual aid and community.The difference in love refers to the fact that among the many schools of thought in the pre-Qin period, Confucianism advocated "benevolence".
It is a broad and profound love that extends from the individual to the collective, and from humans to all things in nature. It is based on emotions, promotes virtue, embraces ideals, and is grounded in reality, involving multiple aspects such as humanitarian care, moral cultivation, benevolent governance, and social education.
Fei Xiaotong's"differentiated love"in Confucianism means we love our family more intensely, and this love gradually extends to others. It's about starting with strong family bonds and widening our care to the wider community. It's a practical approach that grows love from the personal to the universal level.
Confucianism does emphasize that love has differences in degree based on kinship. It believes that one naturally has a stronger love and closer bond with family members due to blood relations and the importance of family in Confucian values.However, Confucian love doesn't stop at family. It extends outward in a hierarchical and orderly manner. As Mencius said, it shows as "loving one's family, then showing benevolence to the people, and finally loving all things."
The Confucian concept of "benevolence and love" is not limited to blood ties within families, but can be extended to a wider range of social groups. Confucius emphasized the ideas of "universal love for all" and "the world is for all", indicating that Confucian benevolence is a universal love that is not limited to family or blood relationships. The Confucian spirit of benevolence and love needs to be creatively interpreted and innovatively developed in modern society, combining factors such as filial piety, brotherly love, universal love, individual and society, emotion and rationality, morality and rule of law, to meet the needs of modern society.
Therefore, Fei Xiaotong's "hierarchical pattern" and the Confucian concept of "benevolence" do not imply that love for the family is stronger than love for others, but rather that the degree and manner of love are adjusted based on the closeness and distance of the relationship. Moreover, the Confucian spirit of benevolence needs to be innovated and developed in modern society by combining modern value elements.
Differentiated benevolence is a key concept in Confucian philosophy, advocating that love should vary based on the closeness of relationships. Centered on the family, it emphasizes starting with loved ones and gradually extending outward, forming a hierarchical structure of "closer first, others later." Confucius proposed principles like "affection between father and son, duty between ruler and subject, distinction between husband and wife, order among elders and juniors, and trust among friends," reflecting this idea. Unlike Mozi's "universal love," differentiated benevolence aligns with Confucian realism, focusing on practical morality and maintaining social harmony.
This is wrong perception. As a Chinese saying goes, a country is made up of many small families. Love can wait, but love will pass. The love of the small family becomes the love of the clan, the love of the country. The overall scope of love is variable, not fixed. The ripples created when a stone is thrown into the water also vary depending on the size of the water
Professor Fei Xiaotong's concept of"differentiated love"does not necessarily suggest a stronger love for one's own family at the expense of others.Instead,it implies a graded approach to love,where affection starts from the family and extends outwards in concentric circles to include society at large.In Confucianism,love is not just limited to the family but is meant to be extended to others and eventually to all things in the world.This extension of love is part of achieving harmony within oneself,with others,and with nature,aligning with the Confucian values of benevolence and care for the wider community.
Fei Xiaotong's "differentiated love" in Confucianism suggests that love starts strong with one's family and extends outward with decreasing intensity. This reflects the hierarchical nature of relationships and obligations in Confucian ethics, where family is the core, and moral concern extends but lessens with distance. However, it's not about love growing thinner but about adapting its expression to different relationships.In Confucianism, the extension of love is understood through the concept of "ren" , often translated as benevolence or humaneness, which is the central virtue in Confucian ethics.
Professor Fei Xiaotong's concept of "differentiated love" indeed reflects the Confucian understanding of hierarchical and gradated love. In Confucian philosophy, love is seen as having different levels, primarily based on the closeness and distance of relationships to the individual. Confucians believe that an individual should first display the deepest love and care towards their own family members, as the family is considered the basic unit of society and maintaining family harmony is fundamental to building social order. However, Confucianism does not limit love solely within the family. Confucius advocated for the principle of "Ren" which translates to benevolence or humaneness, suggesting that love should extend to others. The practice of Ren involves showing kindness and consideration to all individuals, thereby fostering a harmonious society.
In Confucianism, the extension of love starts from the love for one's family but it is not limited to it. Confucians believe in "loving others with benevolence." The starting point of love is indeed the family, as the family is the basic unit of society. Loving one's parents and relatives is the foundation. However, this love should be extended outward in concentric circles like ripples on a pond.Confucian love is not a simple quantitative decrease from family to others, but a qualitative expansion based on moral practice.
Certainly.Professor Fei Xiaotong's"differentiated love"in Confucianism suggests that love begins with the family and radiates outward,with varying degrees of intensity based on proximity.It is a structured extension of love that starts from the closest relationships and expands to society at large,rather than a diminishing of love as one moves away from family.This approach reflects a moral practice of love that is both hierarchical and expansive,aiming for social harmony through the cultivation of relationships.
No, this does not necessarily mean that Confucians claim a stronger love toward one's own family while the love grows thinner to others. Rather, Confucianism emphasizes extending one's love and respect beyond the family to society at large.
Professor Fei Xiaotong's concept of"differentiated love,"or"cha序(zhìxù)"which translates to"orderly structure"or"hierarchical structure,"is a description of social relationships in Chinese society.It emphasizes the hierarchical and differential nature of interpersonal relationships.In this theory,love and care expand outward from the individual,starting with the love for one's family and then gradually extending to broader social relationships.This does not mean that the love for one's family is stronger than the love for others;rather,it suggests that love has layers and order.
In Confucianism,the extension of love is achieved through the concept of"仁(rén),"which translates to"benevolence"or"humaneness."Benevolence is a moral virtue that requires individuals to show compassion and care when dealing with others.Confucianism holds that this love should begin with the family and then extend to society and the state.Confucius advocated for"孝(xiào)"and"悌(tì),"which refer to respect and care for parents and siblings,respectively,as the foundation of benevolence.However,this love should not be confined within the family but should extend to care for all members of society.
The concept of benevolence in Confucianism is an inclusive form of love that demands individuals to play appropriate roles in society and act morally.This love is intended to promote social harmony and order.Through education and personal cultivation,Confucianism suggests that individuals can learn how to extend love to broader social relationships,thereby achieving harmony between the individual and society.
In summary,Confucianism does not advocate that love for one's family is stronger than love for others.Instead,it emphasizes the hierarchical and expansive nature of love,as well as the importance of personal cultivation and education in achieving this extension of love.(Note:The term"cha序(zhìxù)"does not have a direct English equivalent and is translated here as"orderly structure"to convey the idea of a structured hierarchy in relationships.)
The concept of "differentiated benevolence," as described by Fei Xiaotong, is a way to understand the traditional Chinese approach to social relationships. This concept suggests that relationships radiate outward from the individual, much like ripples in a pond, with the closest relationships being the strongest and the further ones becoming progressively weaker.
In Confucian thought, this does not mean that there is a claim for stronger love towards one's own family while the love for others diminishes. Instead, it reflects a structured approach to love and care, where the love and responsibility one has for others are graded based on the closeness of the relationship.
Confucianism advocates for a universal form of benevolence known as "ren," which is to be practiced towards all people. However, the practical application of this benevolence is nuanced, with the expression and degree of love being adjusted according to the proximity of relationships. This approach does not devalue the love for those outside the immediate family but rather recognizes the natural human tendency to have stronger emotional bonds with those closest to us.
Thus, Confucianism promotes an ordered love that starts within the family and gradually extends to society at large. This perspective encapsulates the Confucian understanding of social harmony and the importance of maintaining order within interpersonal relationships to achieve both personal moral development and societal cohesion.
1.In Confucian philosophy, “differentiated benevolence” is closely related to the thoughts of Confucius and Mencius. Confucius proposed “ren” (仁) as the highest moral value, emphasizing love for others. Mencius further developed Confucius’s concept of ren, proposing the “innate goodness of human nature,” suggesting that humans are inherently good because they are born with moral sprouts (端) that can be cultivated and expanded through moral reflection (思) and analogical reasoning (推). Mencius’s “ren” is a differentiated love that starts with love for one’s family and gradually extends to love for others, eventually reaching love for all things.
2. Research indicates that people interpret and handle “differentiated benevolence” through different logics when faced with moral dilemmas. For example, in the United States, people understand and explain how to help others in moral dilemmas through empathy, exemption, and prudence. Empathy refers to the idea that those seeking help are imperfect and fallible, deserving of support; exemption suggests that intimate relationships make unusual help reasonable; prudence allows morally opposed helpers to separate their personal moral objections from the moral decisions of those seeking abortions.
3. “Differentiated benevolence” plays a significant role in sociological theory. It extends the literature on moral decision-making, focusing on dyadic relationships and revealing the role of benevolence in motivating prosocial behaviors within intimate personal relationships. Most acts of benevolence occur within existing relationships, and studying moral decision-making within individual networks can demonstrate the practice of “differentiated benevolence” and how people understand it.
4. Confucian “ren” can also be interpreted as ecological ethics. On one hand, Confucianism affirms the intrinsic value of the universe and calls for universal moral concern for the ecological world; on the other hand, it recognizes the distinction between humans and nature, revealing differentiated ecological ethical awareness and awareness of differences between different ethical realms. When extracting the instrumental value of ecological resources, Confucianism never overlooks the intrinsic value of plants and animals.
In summary, “differentiated benevolence” is a complex concept that involves morality, social relationships, individual behavior, and environmental ethics, among other aspects. It has different interpretations and applications within different cultures and philosophical systems.
I don't think so, because Confucians does not advocate that love for family is stronger than love for others, but advocates that the practice of love should follow a certain order and level, starting from the closest people and gradually expanding to broader social relations.Confucianism does not advocate that love for family is stronger than love for others, but advocates that the practice of love should follow a certain order and level, starting from the closest people and gradually expanding to broader social relations.
The affection rooted in Confucian philosophy commences within the familial sphere and progressively expands to encompass a love for others and all sentient beings, via the processes of introspection and empathetic understanding. This variety of love is structured in a hierarchical manner, yet ultimately aspires to cultivate harmonious interpersonal relations and maintain social cohesion.
Professor Fei Xiaotongs concept of the differentiated loveindeed reflects the hierarchical understanding of love in Confucian thought.In Confucian culture,love is not dispensed equally to all but begins with the individuals family and gradually extends outward.This love starts with the closest family members and then expands to relatives,friends,the community,and eventually to the nation and the world.The expansion of this love does not imply that love for those outside the family is less important or diminishes;rather,it emphasizes the starting point and foundation of love.Confucianism holds that individuals should first cultivate and practice love within the family and then apply the principles of this love to broader social relationships.The development of this love from the inner circle to the outer is conducive to establishing a harmonious and orderly society.In modern society,this idea can be understood as the starting point for both personal and social responsibility.
The extension of love is also related to the cultivation of an individual's moral self. By constantly expanding love from the family, an individual can improve their moral character. And a person with high moral character can influence others and promote the spread of love in society. For example, a gentleman in Confucianism, through his own moral practice starting from family - centered love, can become an example for others in the community, and gradually make the whole society more harmonious and full of love.
No, Confucians do not necessarily claim that love should be stronger for one's own family and thinner for others. Instead, they advocate for graded love based on relational proximity, where familial love serves as a foundation for broader social relationships and moral responsibilities.
Love in Confucianism starts with the family, where the strongest bonds and responsibilities are felt. From there, it extends to friends, community, and society, with the intensity of love and duty diminishing as the social distance increases. However, this does not mean that one should not care for others outside the family; rather, it acknowledges the natural prioritization of closer relationships while still promoting a universal ethical concern for all people. The goal is to cultivate moral virtues that allow for the harmonious functioning of society, with love and respect being shown to all, but in varying degrees based on relational proximity.
Professor Fei Xiaotong's concept of "differentiated love" indeed touches on a significant aspect of Confucian thought regarding the nature and extension of love. In Confucianism, there is an emphasis on the idea of familial bonds and obligations, where love (or affection) is often prioritized toward one's own family, particularly in the context of filial piety—an essential virtue in Confucian ethics.
The idea of "differentiated love" suggests that individuals have varying degrees of emotional attachment and responsibility toward different people in their lives. In this framework, love for one's family is considered stronger and more immediate because of the inherent obligations and emotional ties that are formed through kinship. Conversely, love for others outside the family may be viewed as more generalized or diluted, as it does not carry the same level of personal responsibility or emotional investment as familial love.
The extension of love in Confucianism can be understood through the concept of "ren" (仁), which is often translated as "benevolence" or "humaneness." "Ren" is a central virtue in Confucian thought and emphasizes the importance of empathy, compassion, and moral integrity in relations with others. While Confucians advocate for a strong love toward one’s family, they also encourage the extension of love and care to society at large, promoting the idea that as individuals cultivate their capacity for love within their families, they should gradually expand that love to encompass broader social relationships.
In this way, Confucianism acknowledges the complexity of human relationships and the varying degrees of love that are appropriate to different contexts. The ideal is not to neglect love for others outside the family but to recognize that relationships are framed by social and moral contexts, where the deepest commitments might lie within the family unit, while still fostering a sense of responsibility and care toward the wider community. Thus, Confucian love can be viewed as a layered and nuanced concept that encourages both deep familial bonds and social responsibility.
Confucianism does not advocate indifference or indifference towards others, but rather that love has a hierarchical structure, and as distance increases, the form and intensity of this love may vary. At the same time, Confucianism also encourages people to strive beyond this natural emotional tendency, cultivate universal compassion and sense of responsibility, in order to achieve social harmony.
Therefore, 'love is unequal' does not equate to selfishness or narrow family values, but rather a guiding principle of social ethics based on human understanding.
Firstly, this kind of love conforms to people's natural emotional tendencies. Starting from family affection, people's love for their parents and children is the most direct and intense. Love based on blood relations is an instinct. For example, children naturally rely on their parents when they are young, and parents will also take care of their children wholeheartedly. This kind of love is easy to be understood and practiced, and it can create a strong affectionate atmosphere within the family and build a stable family relationship.
您确定给 “
4008987008